Authors' Reaction to Book Reviews and DNF
“In my reviews, I feel it's good to make it clear that I'm not proposing objective truth, but subjective reactions..." ― Roger Ebert Roger Ebert was a great American film critic who, along with the equally great Gene Siskel, awarded “Two Thumbs Up” to deserving films. Ebert was considered the most influential and powerful film pundit in America. Though I don’t review films, I follow Ebert’s “relative, not absolute" approach when reviewing indie books. But sometimes, authors react as if reviews are absolute truths. The way I see it, a review is really an exercise in reaction and counter-reaction: When a book gets a glowing 5-star review... When a book gets a 4-star review... When a book gets a 3-star review... When a book gets a 2-star review... When a book gets a 1-star review And the ultimate reaction when a book is marked 'DID NOT FINISH' (or DNF) ...